Single in Your 20sTake the quiz

Dating when you want to

The November Theory: is the calendar deciding for you?

The idea going around this month: November is when talking stages either turn into something or quietly end. There's a little research under it, and a lot of vibes on top. Here's how to tell which part applies to the person you're texting.

A woman in a rust corduroy jacket laughs while lacing ice skates on a rinkside bench beside a man in a green sweater at dusk
Illustration. AI-generated image.
Jump to a section
  1. The part with some evidence behind it
  2. The part that’s mostly vibes
  3. Using November without letting it pick for you
  4. How far this goes

Halloween is over, the decorations went straight to turkeys, and your feed has a new idea for you: the November Theory. The short version is that November decides things. Talking stages either get serious or quietly end, because the holidays force questions a new couple has been avoiding.

Vice wrote it up on November 1, quoting matchmaker Susan Trombetti, who describes the month as a test that starts with questions like “Should I bring this person home to meet the family?” and “Do I want to start the new year with this person?”1 She also ties it to cuffing season: colder weather, more wanting to be paired up.

None of that is a study. It’s a name for a feeling a lot of people have in late fall. So it’s worth splitting the theory into the part that has some support and the part that’s mostly calendar anxiety.

The part with some evidence behind it

Researchers haven’t studied November specifically. They have studied another holiday with a lot of relationship pressure attached. In a 2004 study of college students, breakups were more common around Valentine’s Day than at comparison times. The interesting detail is who broke up: the holiday mostly seemed to speed along relationships that were already weakening, rather than knocking over healthy ones.2

That’s one study, one holiday, one campus population, so treat it as a hint, not a law. But if it carries over at all, it suggests the holidays don’t create problems. They make it harder to keep ignoring ones that were already there.

The other piece is about talking. A 2017 study followed 244 emerging adults and looked at “sliding” (drifting into the next stage without discussing it) versus “deciding” (talking it through). Sliding went along with more uncertainty and was followed by lower dedication and satisfaction later on.3 That’s a correlation, and it doesn’t prove that one awkward conversation fixes anything. It does line up with the useful half of the November Theory: the month puts a question on the table, and the couples who answer it out loud seem to do better than the ones who let it drift.

The part that’s mostly vibes

The theory treats November like a deadline. Nothing in the research above says a new relationship has to settle anything by the end of the year.

It’s also part of a genre. Two weeks before the November write-up, Vice covered the 3-6-9 rule, which splits the first nine months into a honeymoon phase, a conflict stage and a decision stage. Trombetti said in that piece that the idea isn’t new, it just has a catchy name.5 Same here. A catchy frame is fine for starting a conversation. It’s a bad replacement for having one.

And the pressure to find someone this month may feel stronger because more people your age are out there trying. In a Bloomberg Intelligence survey of 1,000 US dating app users fielded August 26 to September 21, 2026, 34% of those aged 16 to 28 said they were single and currently dating, up from 23% the year before.4 That’s app users only, not everyone in their twenties. Still, a busier field can make standing still feel like falling behind.

Using November without letting it pick for you

You don’t need a holiday to decide. You do need to know what you’re actually unsure about. Three questions do most of the work:

  1. Is there a real date coming up that needs an answer? A Thanksgiving invite, a work party, a trip home. Start there, because it’s concrete.
  2. Have you ever said what you want this to be? If not, that’s the conversation. The holidays are just a reason to have it now.
  3. Would you still want this in a random week in spring? If the honest answer is “probably not,” the cozy weather is doing a lot of the liking.

If the texting has gone strangely one-sided lately, the late-night-only texter covers that pattern. And if November’s real question is whether you’re the one keeping this alive, the box theory piece looks at how people sort each other early on.

How far this goes

  • “November Theory” is a trend name from a matchmaker and social media, not a research term.
  • The holiday-breakup evidence here is one older study about Valentine’s Day among college students.
  • The sliding-versus-deciding findings are correlational. They describe patterns across people, not what will happen with this particular person.

Try it

What are you secretly hoping November settles?

Whether they're coming home with me for a holiday

That's a real question, and it has a deadline

This is the one piece of the theory that's pure logistics. Tickets, seats at a table, who your aunt asks about. Ask about the plan itself before you ask what it means. 'Are you around for Thanksgiving?' is easier to answer than 'what are we?'

Your next step: Ask about one date on the calendar, not the whole relationship.

Whether this is actually going anywhere

The month didn't create that question

It was already there; the holidays just made it louder. The 2017 sliding-versus-deciding research found that drifting without talking went with more uncertainty later. A short, direct conversation beats waiting for the season to answer for you.

Your next step: Say out loud what you'd want this to be by January.

Whether I even like them, or just like having someone

Cuffing season is a known bias

The trend itself is built on wanting someone to be cozy with when it gets cold. That's a fine reason to date, but a shaky reason to commit. Picture the same person in a random week in April and see if your answer changes.

Your next step: Notice whether you'd text them first on a normal Tuesday.

Nothing. I just don't want to be the one who ends it

Then the theory is doing your dirty work

Letting a holiday be the reason things end means nobody has to say anything. That's comfortable, but it usually leaves both people confused. If it's over for you, it's kinder to say so than to wait for the calendar to make it obvious.

Your next step: Decide what you would say if they asked you first.

Steal this text

Say it in your own words, or start from these

  • Asking about the holidays, low stakes

    Random question, what are you doing for Thanksgiving? I'm trying to figure out my plans.

  • Asking where it's going, without a speech

    I like where this is. Before the holidays get chaotic I'd love to know if we're both thinking of this as something real.

People who talk about this

Labeled by where their authority comes from. Not a ranking, not an endorsement.

  • Credentialed source

Alexandra H. Solomon

Relational self awareness, dating and building lasting relationships, drawn from her couples work and her Northwestern course.

Licensed clinical psychologist; adjunct professor, School of Education and Social Policy, Northwestern University · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Bella DePaulo

Research and writing on single life, including people who choose to stay single and live full lives on their own terms.

Social psychologist (PhD, Harvard); academic affiliate, Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, UC Santa Barbara · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Marisa G. Franco

Friendship, loneliness and belonging, and how adults make and keep close friends.

Licensed counseling psychologist; PhD in Counseling Psychology, University of Maryland, where she teaches · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source
  • Trending voice

Nedra Glover Tawwab

Boundaries in relationships, family and friendship, and how to say what you need.

Licensed therapist; founder of Kaleidoscope Counseling · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

All 6 people we point to →

Sources

  1. What Is the 'November Theory'? The Dating Trend That Could Make or Break Your Relationship.Vice (Sammi Caramela), 2026-11-01Used for: Describes the November Theory as the idea that the holiday season pushes new couples to deepen or end things; matchmaker Susan Trombetti frames it around questions like whether to bring someone home and whether you want to start the new year with them, and ties it to cuffing season.
  2. How do holidays influence relationship processes and outcomes? Examining the instigating and catalytic effects of Valentine's DayPersonal Relationships (Morse and Neuberg), 2004Used for: In a study of college students, breakups were more common in the period around Valentine's Day than at comparison times, and the holiday seemed to speed up the end of relationships that were already weakening rather than causing breakups in healthy ones.
  3. Testing the impact of sliding versus deciding in cyclical and noncyclical relationshipsPersonal Relationships (Clifford, Vennum, Busk and Fincham), 2017Used for: In a longitudinal sample of 244 emerging adults, sliding through relationship transitions without talking about them went along with more uncertainty and was followed by lower dedication and satisfaction. Correlational.
  4. Bloomberg survey finds 34% of 16-to-28s dating, up from 23%Dating Industry Insights (Kim Harris), 2026-10-28Used for: Reports a Bloomberg Intelligence survey of 1,000 US dating app users, fielded August 26 to September 21, 2026, in which 34% of those aged 16 to 28 said they were single and currently dating, up from 23% the year before. App users only.
  5. The '3-6-9 Dating Rule' Might Explain Why So Many Relationships Fall ApartVice (Sammi Caramela), 2026-10-20Used for: Describes the TikTok 3-6-9 rule, which splits the first nine months into a honeymoon phase, a conflict stage and a long-term decision stage; Trombetti says it is not a new idea, just one with a catchy name.
Up nextThey ghosted you, then came back. Now what?